Roofing Materials

roofing-materials

Are you pondering a new roof? Wondering what type of material might be best for your home?

There are many types of roofing materials—some of which are brand new—with a range of plusses and negatives. You can re-roof with the same type of roofing material that you currently have or investigate alternatives. Some materials are environmentally friendly and some are long lasting or low maintenance. And who doesn’t love low maintenance?

Before making your choice, consider the life-cycle cost of your roofing material. Some materials, though much more expensive, require less maintenance and have a longer life expectancy than others. An asphalt composition roof might last just 20 years whereas a metal roof might last more than 50. Consider both the current and potential value of your home, and its age when calculating whether a roofing material is actually “too expensive.” It might just be more cost-effective in the long run.

The following table describes some of the roofing choices available:

Roof Type House Style Advantages Disadvantages
Composition (asphalt shingles)
Can be used on any house from contemporary to historic. False thatched roof with the wrapped roof edge on 1920s Tudor style.
  • inexpensive
  • ranges from low-cost 3-tab shingle to architectural shingles with extra durability and style
  • many colors, types, and manufacturers
  • suitable for most residential applications
  • easy to repair
  • fire resistant
  • relatively short life-span (15–30 years)
  • scars easily when hot
  • subject to mildew and moss
  • environmentally unfriendly
Wood shingles or shakes
Cedar Shingles
Bungalows, ranch, contemporary, cottage, historic
  • natural look weathering to a soft grey
  • offers some insulation value
  • blends in with the environment
  • easy to repair or replace
  • long lasting if maintained (30–50 years)
  • expensive
  • usually requires professional installation
  • high maintenance
  • tends to rot, split, mold, and mildew
  • poor fire rating unless presure treated
Metal (steel, aluminum, tin, copper)
copper metal roof
Bungalows, ranch, contemporary, cottage, historic (virtually all)
  • available in different looks including cedar shingles, slate, or standing seam
  • many colors
  • light weight
  • durable
  • long life span (at least 50 years)
  • low maintenance
  • can be installed over existing roofs
  • excellent performance in high wind, hail and rain
  • environmentally friendly
  • may be difficult to install
  • can be expensive
  • may need periodic painting
Tile (concrete, clay)
Cement Tiles
Mediterranean, Italian, French Eclectic, Spanish Eclectic, Beaux Arts, Mission, and Prairie. May also be attractive on some contemporary or ranch style homes.
  • non-combustible
  • many colors and styles
  • attractive
  • fireproof
  • easy to maintain
  • extremely durable when maintained
  • expensive
  • heavy
  • used primarily in new buildings because of weight and structural requirements
  • installation and repairs can be tricky
  • fragile; walking on roof may break tiles
Slate
Slate
Colonial, French, Italianate, Exotic Revivals, Chateauesque, Beaux Arts
  • beautiful, distinctive appearance
  • fireproof
  • long life span
  • low maintenance
  • very expensive
  • requires specialized installation
  • heavy
  • fragile
  • high maintenance
Concrete (fiber reinforced)
Virtually any style of home
  • many colors and styles including shakes, tile, and stone
  • relatively lightweight
  • fire and insect resistant; meet many of the more restrictive fire codes
  • low maintenance
  • extremely durable
  • resource efficient
  • can be expensive
  • uneven quality among products
Hot mopped asphalt with decorative stone
Flat roofed California-style modern
  • inexpensive
  • easy to repair
  • stinks
  • health risk to installers
  • fumes promote smog
Engineered rubber/plastic
Virtually any style of home
  • about 1/3 the weight of slate
  • long lasting (30–50 years)
  • cost effective
  • attractive
  • available in a large range of styles and colors with more appearing constantly
  • made of reclaimed materials
  • new to market
Eco-roofs
Flat to moderately sloped roofs.
  • Environmentally friendly; filters rainwater through a roof system of vegetation and soil
  • Low maintenance; can extend the life of the roof membrane substantially
  • Provides insulation to even out climate variations; in particular, keeps houses cooler in summer
  • Attractive
  • initially expensive
  • unconventional in US, though used more than 30 years in Europe

Roofs Styles Represent

A roof symbolizes the essence of shelter and protection while embodying the notion of our home as sanctuary. The roof shields us from the elements, keeps us comfortable inside and provides us with the security we need.

A roof reflects the spaces it encloses while shaping the stylistic character of the building it covers. It speaks to the site it inhabits, the climate it tangles with and the neighborhood it adjoins. Since the roof can take on a multitude of forms and shapes it must be carefully considered on a number of levels, from the practical to the abstract, to create a successful architectural composition.

On the most pragmatic level, a roof needs to respond to the climate it occupies. Steeper slopes shed rain and snow better than flatter ones and are generally a good choice in climates that experience large amounts of precipitation. Roofing materials such as metal, asphalt shingles, tile and slate all have different minimum and maximum slope restrictions in their application and require some forethought before being specified. A flat roof would never be clad in cedar shakes just as a steep roof would never be covered with tar and gravel.

Architects generally refer to roof slope as a ratio of vertical rise over a given horizontal run. The convention is to use the number 12 for the horizontal dimension giving us roof pitches described as 2:12, 10:12, etc. — the bigger the first number, the steeper the slope.

You rarely find steep slopes on the traditional bungalow because of the simple overriding factor of cost. Steeper roofs require more framing material to build and more roofing material to cover. This simple reality produces a rather generic roof slope that is steep enough to meet the restrictions of most roofing materials while still being shallow enough to be economical. It sits somewhere around 5:12 and has created a fairly bland housing landscape that could afford a little variation.

Roofs with different slopes call to mind different styles. A steep forested site might suggest one type of roof while a flat, wide open site might suggest another.

The Prairie Style of architecture, best illustrated by the work of Frank Lloyd Wright, was founded in the American Midwest and tried to evoke the flatness of its native landscape through the use of horizontal line. By using flat and shallow sloped hip roofs with large overhangs, Wright and his peers were able to create buildings that were inextricably linked to their “prairie” landscape.

In addition to responding to the site it inhabits, the roof should also reflect the plan it contains. Just as a simple plan warrants a simple roof arrangement, a complex plan, with any number of major and minor elements, requires a more involved roofscape layout.

In these complex situations architects will think of the compositional balance between the larger and smaller roof forms. The building will be anchored in some way by a dominant roof element with smaller more subsidiary roof forms joining to it. The arrangement becomes a sculptural exercise with the overall balance being key to the building’s success.

he largest of the great French chateaux in the Loire Valley is the Chateau de Chambord. At over 400 feet in width this amazing structure houses 440 rooms and is crowned by a forest of turrets, chimneys (365 of them) and dormers stretching across a roof of steep gables and turrets. Although compositionally complex Chateau de Chambord’s roof is in perfect balance and, without question, is one of the most miraculous ever built.

Balancing the very real pragmatic concerns of protection and shelter with the more abstract ones of style and appearance is essential for the design of a successful roof and ultimately a successful building.

The Old Grey Roof Just Ain’t What It Used To Be

One of the great pleasures of remodeling is the opportunity to upgrade your lifestyle. Think of all the great things you can get with a remodel – more space, more luxury, more storage, better efficiency, better flow for entertaining, cooking etc. Maybe even a super cool bathtub big enough for a grownup. Unfortunately, some remodels just can’t deliver the goods. Every once in a while you just need to take the money that should have delivered a super custom grill center, new deck and great seating area and instead sink it into something PRACTICAL. Like a roof.

Now you might figure that living in beautiful coastal Los Angeles that I don’t really need a roof, and for 10 months of the year you would be right. But unfortunately, in a wet year we can get a foot or two of rain. So my wife says we need a roof over our heads.

Until recently, that hasn’t been much of a problem. You see, we were very astute shoppers when we bought our home a few years ago. We picked one that ALREADY HAD A ROOF. Feeling smart and smug, we’ve been getting along just fine with our old grey roof. old roof ready for replacement

It’s so high up off the ground, you have to kind of squint to see it, and it’s always looked smooth and dry. Until the winds came. This April Los Angeles had several weeks of strong, hard winds. (not Florida winds, or Kansas tornado watch winds, but good solid 45-50 mph winds roaring through like a freight train.) Since my house sits on a ridgeline, Easterly winds have a clear shot at my house. Nothing to slow them down as far as the eye can see. When the wind blows at my house you can feel it in your bones. And this year, it managed to get under our skin. Or at least under the roof tiles.

peeling up roof tiles

The next morning we started finding old grey roof tiles out on the sidewalk, in the street and down in the backyard. For a day or two we pretended that it was somebody elses roof blowing away. But soon enough we walked down the block, looked back up our hill and could see the gaping hole on the north slope of our roof. No deck for me. I was getting a roof.

(Okay, I confess, we did put it off for a month or two to match better with my work schedule.)

Step one on any significant remodeling job is to pick the right contractor. The first step is to make a list of who you know, and who you trust who can give you the best referrals. Who’s done a similar project recently? Who’s in the business? I’m lucky. One of my friends owns a number of rental properties, and has always been able to recommend high quality contractors who price out well below the “retail” price.

After a bit of looking around, some preliminary estimates from other contractors we chose his guy. Easy to talk to, the great eference and 50% of his normal retail price. Now lets hope that what they say about low bidders isn’t true. our roofer crew

So here we are on a bright, sunny May morning, with 4 men on my roof, (well on what’s left of my roof). There’s a truck in the driveway, and loads of old roof flying through the air going thunk.

old roof shingles

To be continued…

[Originally posted at remodel.net.]

Green Roofing Video

Green roofing video

Tips to Find a Roofing Contractor

Consumers are leery about hiring roofers. The same issues seem to dominate their complaints.

  • Do they have a current business license?
  • Do they provide an official lien waiver WHEN THEY FINISH THE JOB?
    If your roofing contractor doesn’t pay their supplier, the supplier could put a lien on your home until the debt is paid! Make absolutely sure your contractor signs a lien release form clearing you of any liability.
  • Do they provide you with a letter from the roofing material manufacturer stating that they are certified to be installing their product on your home? Some roof manufacturers require that the contractor go through training and be certified to install their product. If your contractor hasn’t done this, chances are that your warranty will be worthless.
  • Are they insured with both Worker’s Compensation for their employees, as well as Liability Insurance for your home?
    This is critical. If they are not insured, then YOU take the risk if someone gets hurt or something gets damaged. You are entitled to have a copy of these certificates.
  • Do they take the time to inspect your attic and educate you on the necessity of proper attic ventilation?
    The manufacturer will void the shingle warranty if the attic isn’t property ventilated.
  • Do they provide you with the most extensive warranty available on labor and material?
    Do they provide you with a 5-year reference list with at least 1,000 customers?
    Any good roofer that has been in business for at least 5 years can give you the names and addresses of at least 1,000 customers.